International scientists have uncovered prehistoric human DNA of two extinct human relatives – the Neanderthals, and the Denisovans- from caves without bones, an advance that could shed new light on human history and evolution.
The technique could be valuable for reconstructing human evolutionary history, according to the study published on Thursday in the journal Science.
That’s because fossilised bones, currently the main source of ancient DNA, are scarce even at sites where circumstantial evidence points to a prehistoric human presence.
“There are many caves where stone tools are found but no bones,” said Matthias Meyer, a geneticist at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, who co-authored the study.
The researchers collected 85 sediment samples from seven caves in Europe and Russia that humans are known to have entered or even lived during the Pleistocene, between 14,000 and 550,000 years ago.
By refining a method previously used to find plant and animal DNA, they were able to search specifically for genetic material belonging to ancient humans and other mammals.
“This work represents an enormous scientific breakthrough,” said Antonio Rosas, scientist at Spain’s Natural Science Museum in Madrid.
“We can now tell which species of hominid occupied a cave and on which particular stratigraphic level, even when no bone or skeletal remains are present.”
Scientists focused on mitochondrial DNA, which is passed down the maternal line, because it is particularly suited to telling apart closely related species. By analysing damaged molecules they were able to separate ancient genetic material from any contamination left behind by modern visitors
“The technique could increase the sample size of the Neanderthal and Denisovan mitochondrial genomes, which until now were limited by the number of preserved remains,” explained Spanish National Research Council scientist Carles Lalueza-Fox.
“And it will probably be possible to even recover substantial parts of nuclear genomes.”
The researchers found evidence of 12 mammal families including extinct species such as woolly mammoth, woolly rhinoceros, cave bear and cave hyena.
By further enriching the samples for human-like DNA, however, the scientists were able to detect genetic traces of Denisovans – a mysterious lineage of ancient humans first discovered in a cave in Siberia – and Neanderthals from samples taken at four sites.
Crucially, one of the sites where they discovered Neanderthal DNA was a cave in Belgium, known as Trou Al’Wesse, where no human bones had ever been found, though stone artifacts and animal bones with cut marks strongly suggested people had visited it.
Eske Willerslev, who helped pioneer the search for DNA in sediment but wasn’t involved in the latest research, said the new study was an interesting step, but cautioned that it’s difficult to determine how old sediment samples found in caves are.
“In general (it) is very disturbed and unless you can show that’s not the case you have no idea of the date of the findings,” said Mr Willerslev, an evolutionary geneticist at the University of Copenhagen, Denmark.
Mr Meyer said the new method greatly increases the number of sites where archaeologists will be able to find genetic evidence to help fill gaps in the history of human evolution and migration, such as how widespread Neanderthal populations were and which stone tools they were able to make.
“In principle, every cave where there’s evidence of human activity now offers this possibility,” Mr Meyer told The Associated Press.