Feb. 15, 2011 — Men who start to go bald by age 20 may have an increased risk for developing prostate cancer later in life, a study suggests.
The findings appear to contradict research published last spring, which found early baldness to be protective against prostate cancer. But that study contradicted even earlier research suggesting just the opposite.
Cancer experts tell WebMD that the evidence linking baldness to prostate cancer remains inconclusive.
“This really just shows how much we don’t know,” American Cancer Society Director of Prostate and Colorectal Cancers Durado D. Brooks, MD, tells WebMD.
“Even if this research is corroborated, the message is not clear,” he explains. “If you are a 20-year-old man and you are balding, the most that can be said based on this latest study is that you might develop prostate cancer in 40 years.”
Losing Hair Early in Life
In the new study, published Tuesday in the Annals of Oncology, researchers found no evidence that specific patterns of hair loss were more closely linked to prostate cancer than others. The study also failed to show an association between early hair loss and the diagnosis of prostate cancer earlier in life.
The association between hair loss and prostate cancer was also not seen in men who reported that they began losing their hair at age 30 or 40.
“All that we can really say from this research is that men who are balding at age 20 appear to have an increased risk for prostate cancer,” radiation oncologist and study researcher Michael Yassa, MD, tells WebMD. “These other associations may exist, but we were not able to show them.”
About one in four men with male pattern baldness starts to lose his hair before age of 21 and two out of three will experience some hair thinning by age 35, according to the American Hair Loss Association.
Known medically as androgenic alopecia, male pattern baldness is caused by both genetics and hormones, but the specific relationship between the two is not completely understood.
It is believed that the androgen dihydrotesterone (DHT), which is a product of the male hormone testosterone, is produced in high amounts in genetically susceptible men. At these high levels DHT appears to cause the hair follicles to shrink over time, causing the hair to become weak and, eventually, stop growing.
DHT has also been implicated in the development and growth of prostate cancer.
The drug Propecia blocks the conversion of testosterone to DHT. Several widely publicized studies also suggest that it may prevent prostate cancer in high-risk men.
In an effort to better understand the DHT connection, Yassa and colleagues from France’s European Georges Pompidou Hospital asked close to 400 prostate cancer patients and around 400 men without the disease about their balding history.
A total of 37 participants with a history of prostate cancer and 14 participants without reported some degree of balding by the age of 20, including receding hairline and/or thinning of the hair on top of the head.
Yassa says the research could help identify men who might benefit from prostate cancer screening.
“There is a huge debate right now about who should be screened and whether screening is appropriate for the general population,” he says, adding that men with early balding may be good candidates for screening.
But Brooks is not convinced.
“There is really nothing here that should alter the recommendation of the American Cancer Society and other groups that men should learn all they can about the potential risks and benefits of prostate cancer screening and then make a decision about whether or not to be screened,” he says.
American Cancer Society Chief Medical Officer Otis Brawley, MD, agrees.
“We have not moved beyond speculation at this point,” he tells WebMD. “There is no reason for bald men to obsess about this.”